ITSS问题管理中经常遇到哪些方面的困难
20150924 淡然
续上
5.4 问题管理评估问题
Level 1:基础 |
1. Are at least some problem management activities established in the organisation, e.g. problem determination, problem analysis, problem resolution? |
2. Are problem management activities assigned to specific individuals or functional areas? |
3. Is there a procedure by which significant incidents are escalated by incident management? |
4. Are potential problems formally assessed and identified prior to disruption occurring? |
Level 1.5: 管理意识 |
5. Has the purpose and benefits of problem management been disseminated within the organisation? |
6. Does the organisation have procedures for the registration of problems and their resolution? |
7. Is there management commitment to support staff allocating sufficient time for structural problem solving activities? |
8. Is the organisation committed to reducing the total number of problems and the number of incidents that interrupt the conduct of business? |
9. Is there management support for problem management staff only accepting support requests from authorised sources? |
Level 2: 流程 |
10. Have responsibilities for various problem management activities been assigned? |
11. Is there a procedure for analysing significant, recurring and unresolved incidents and identifying underlying problems? |
12. Is there a procedure by which potential problems are classified, in terms of category, urgency, priority and impact and assigned for investigation? |
13. Do problem owners have adequate guidelines for identifying and recording the nature of a problem? |
14. Are complex problem investigations across for example, several technical areas adequately co-ordinated? |
15. Is there a procedure for problem closure? |
16. Do you have a mechanism for tracking problem resolution? ITSS认证 |
17. Do you monitor the effectiveness of problem support areas? |
Level 2.5: 内部集成 |
18. Is the nature of the problem always documented as part of the problem record? |
19. Is Problem Management responsible for the completeness of all problem records? |
20. Does problem management escalate problems with severe impact to the CAB to increase the priority of the RFC or to implement an urgent change as appropriate. |
21. Are proposed solutions to a problem reviewed and authorised by a third party? |
22. Are problem records updated to reflect the progress in resolving the problem? |
23. Is the Problem Manager responsible for reviewing the problem records? |
Level 3: 工具 |
24. Are standard reports concerning problems produced regularly? |
25. Are problem records updated on resolution of a problem? |
26. Are requests for change raised on the basis of problem analysis? |
27. Do problem management reports comment on the results of proactive problem management? |
Minimum score to achieve this level: 'Y' for all mandatory ('M') questions + 1 other answer 'Y' |
Level 3.5: 质量控制 |
28. Are the standards and other quality criteria made explicit and applied to problem management activities? |
29. Are the personnel responsible for problem mangement activities suitably trained? |
30. Does the organisation set and review either targets or objectives for Problem Management? |
31. Does the organisation use suitable tools to support the problem management process? |
Level 4:管理报告 |
32. Does Problem Management provide management with information concerning analysis of problem records? |
33. Does Problem Management provide management with information concerning recurring problems of a particular type or with an individual item? |
34. Does Problem Management provide management with information concerning the need for more customer training or better documentation? |
35. Does Problem Management provide management with information concerning trends in problem distribution and potential 'hot' spots? |
Level 4.5: 外部沟通 |
36. Do you hold regular meetings with interested parties in which Problem Management (PM) matters are discussed? |
37. Does PM exchange information with Configuration Management regarding the quality of configuration records, highlighting any issues, and the potential flagging of items as 'failed' (or equivalent)? |
38. Does PM exchange information with Change Management regarding the details of any changes to resolve problems or on emergency actions undertaken? |
39. Does PM exchange information with Incident Management for identification of significant incidents or multiple incidents exhibiting common symptoms in order to identify problems? |
40. Does PM exchange information with the Service Desk concerning related incidents, or follow-up on initial handling and possible feedback to users (e.g. via urgent bulletins for major incidents)? |
41. Does PM exchange information with Service Level Management regarding priority handling of problems and potential impact on service level agreement performance? |
42. Does PM exchange information with IT Service Continuity Management regarding possible contingency actions in the event of a major outage? |
43. Does PM exchange information with Availability Management for detection and avoidance of problems and incidents? |
44. Does PM exchange information with Release Management (if applicable) regarding current CIs and for possible association of problems with specific CIs? |
45. Does PM exchange information with Capacity Management for potential implications of planning options, and the likely effect on problem trends? |
Level 5: 客户界面 |
42. Do you check with the customer that the activities performed by Problem Management adequately support their business needs? |
43. Do you check with the customer that they are happy with the services provided? |
44. Are you actively monitoring trends in customer satisfaction? |
45. Are you feeding customer survey information into the service improvement agenda? |
46. Are you monitoring the customer's value perception of the services provided to them? |
Level 1: 基础 |
1. Are at least some change management activities established in the organisation, e.g. logging of change requests, change assessments, change planning, change implementation reviews? |
2. Are change management activities assigned to specific individuals or functional areas? |
3. Is there a procedure for raising and issuing requests for change? |
Level 1.5: 管理目的 |
4. Has the purpose and benefits of change management been disseminated within the organisation? |
5. Has the scope of change management activity been established within the organisation? |
6. Does the organisation have standards or other quality criteria for the raising and registering of changes? |
Level 2: 流程 |
7. Have responsibilities for various change management activities been assigned? |
8. Are the procedures for initiating change always adhered to? |
9. Is there a procedure for approving, verifying and scheduling changes? |
10. Are the business and technical impacts of changes always assessed? |
11. Is change progress monitored adequately by Change Management? |
12. Is the successful implementation of a change confirmed by Change Management? |
13. Is there a procedure for the review of all changes? |
14. Are adequate change management reports produced? |
Level 2.5: 内部管理 |
15. Are all changes initiated through the agreed change management channels, for example a Change Advisory Board? |
16. Are changes planned and prioritised, centrally or by common agreement? |
17. Are change records maintained to reflect the progress of changes? |
18. Are the reasons for change failure explicitly recorded and evaluated? |
19. Are successful changes reviewed against the original business needs? |
Level 3: 工具 |
20. Are formal change records maintained? |
21. Is a change schedule of approved changes routinely issued? |
22. Are standard reports on changes produced on a regular basis? |
23. Are there established standards for documenting changes? |
Level 3.5: 质量控制 |
24. Are there standards and other quality criteria for the documentation of change made explicit and applied? |
25. Are the personnel responsible for change management activities suitably trained? |
26. Does the organisation set and review either targets or objectives for Change Management? |
27. Does the organisation use any tools to support the change management process? |
Level 4:管理报告 |
28. Does Change Management provide pertinent information concerning requests for change received (e.g. a breakdown of reasons for changes)? |
29. Does Change Management provide pertinent information concerning the change schedule? |
30. Does Change Management provide pertinent information concerning number and % of changes? |
31. Does Change Management provide pertinent information concerning number of successful and failed changes? |
32. Does Change Management provide pertinent information concerning business impact of changes? ITSS考试 |
33. Does Change Management provide pertinent information concerning change slippage (including backlogs and bottlenecks)? |
34. Does Change Management provide pertinent information concerning number of problem record initiated changes? |
Level 4.5: 外部沟通 |
35. Do you hold regular meetings with interested parties in which Change Management matters are discussed? |
36. Does CM exchange information with Configuration Management regarding change progress and change closure? |
37. Does CM exchange information with Configuration Management regarding change impact assessment on configuration items? |
38. Does CM exchange information with Problem Management regarding changes required to resolve problems / known errors? |
39. Does CM exchange information with Problem Management regarding progress reporting and for receiving problem escalation reports? |
40. Does CM exchange information with Problem Management regarding obtaining problem information relating to change? |
41. Does CM exchange information with the Service Desk for notification of change progress? |
42. Does CM exchange information with the Service Desk for notification of change schedule? |
43. Does CM exchange information with the Service Desk for assessing impact of change on Service Desk support levels? |
44. Does CM exchange information with the Service Desk for obtaining information concerning incidents and calls relating to change? |
45. Does CM exchange information with Release Management concerning change implementation? |
46. Does CM exchange information with Release Management concerning the notification and scheduling of software and hardware releases? |
47. Does CM exchange information with Service Level Management regarding the change schedule? |
48. Does CM exchange information with Service Level Management regarding potential change impact on service level agreements? |
49. Does CM exchange information with IT Service Continuity Management for notification of change schedule? |
50. Does CM exchange information with IT Service Continuity Management for assessing impact of change on contigency plans? |
51. Does CM exchange information with Capacity Management regarding performance and capacity issues relating to change? |
Level 5: 客户界面 |
52. Do you check with the customer if the activities performed by Change Management adequately support their business needs? |
53. Do you check with the customer that they are happy with the services provided? |
54. Are you actively monitoring trends in customer satisfaction? |
55. Are you feeding customer survey information into the service improvement agenda? |
56. Are you monitoring the customers value perception of the services provided to them? |
Process Dimension |
How clear are the process objectives, policies & procedures? How well are they documented and communicated? |
How effective & efficient is the process implementation? To what level are best practices (as defined by ITSM) followed? |
Is the process followed at all times? Is conformance actively monitored? Are there significant consequences to non-conformance? |
Is there effective and timely information flow from/to other processes? How well are the information needs of other processes met, and vice versa? |
How well are process metrics monitored and reported? Are there effective feedback and continuous process improvement activities. |
Organizational Dimension |
Are the organizational structure and underlying corporate culture conducive of effective process-based IT Management? |
Is there a single accountable process owner? How well is that role defined and executed? |
Are there clear, documented roles and responsibilities? Do roles have adequate authorities that are accepted and understood? |
Are skills adequate for assigned roles and responsibilities? Are skill gaps continually assessed and addressed? |
Is people performance measurement strongly linked to process performance within the assigned roles and responsibilities? ITSS培训 |
Technology Dimension |
To what degree do tools automate process steps? Do tools significantly improve productivity? |
Do tools facilitate sharing of information? Do they integrate effectively across processes? |
Do tools provide adequate functionality in addressing all process steps? |
Can common functions be effectively used by typical and/or available skill sets? |
Are the tools archaic? Or are they based on state of the art technologies and frameworks? |
本帖关键字:ITSS